All in the Family Pizzeria

4.3 (16 reviews )
$$
Pizza restaurant
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
+(8)

About All in the Family Pizzeria

At All in the Family Pizzeria, located in Colonie, NY, pizza isn't just food—it's a family passion. Founded with love, this Italian-inspired pizzeria has quickly become a cherished spot for locals seeking authentic New York-style pizza. The menu shines with standout offerings like their specialty Meatball Parm pizza and crispy chicken wings, both crafted with fresh ingredients. Customers rave about the perfectly chewy and crispy crust, highlighting every slice's flavorful toppings. The friendly, welcoming staff make each visit memorable, ensuring a warm, homey atmosphere. Here, every meal is an invitation to join the family at the table.

Reviews (16) 4.3

  • Kym C.
    Nov 10,2024

    I've been ordering pizza from them maybe every other weekend. It always arrives in a timely manner. The pizza is the best (fresh mushrooms) not canned. The bone in chicken wings are crispy yet juicy. Delivery drivers are pleasant. They haven't failed me yet. A much try!!!

  • Paul B.
    Nov 2,2024

    This has just become one of my TOP 5 Pizzerias in the Capital Region. Was looking for a real Italian NY slice. My job sometimes brings me up to the Wolf Rd area and this place is just a short hop from there (and the pizza around Wolf Rd, for the most part, is mediocre at best). Had three slices, bottom crust was crisp & they get the dough right, was about perfectly crispy & chewy, and NOT like the "spongey upstate pizza" (my term!) that I see too much of in our region. One of my slices was their specialty Meatball Parm pizza - this was remarkable, the meatballs were fabulous, the pie was cooked perfectly, nicely topped. I'll plan to bring a pie home in the near future. I originally noted & thought their special pizza slices were perhaps underpriced a bit. After another visit, I realized that all of their counter slices are on a 16" pie, not an 18", so the prices are probably just about right. Tried a white veggie slice this time and the taste was exquisite, nice garlic flavor and roasted veggie pop. Again, outstanding quality of the slices.* The staff (owners?) were super friendly, very service oriented. It really felt like they loved doing what they do and put a lot of love into their cooking. I'm looking forward to trying other menu items when nearby at work again. Though I'm not far, I do wish I lived a little closer!

  • Emma K.
    Oct 25,2024

    Great Pizza pre-fishing. Pretty greasy in the center but it's not pizza if it ain't. I got a 6 slice half pepperoni and half sausage and green peppers (don't knock it till you try it) I ate 4 slices that night and gave one to family for breakfast and the last went to me for breakfast. (First food cheat in a few months) Must have some typa luck to it because Ann Lee Pond is always hit or miss but I got a bass that night when using my new rod for the first time. In colonie let's just say 99% pizza is mid to bad whether it's that they messed up your order or the pizza just SUCKS but I came here that night and they are pretty much the only reason it's 99% and not 100%. That pizza SLAPPED. Got it fresh and hot, along with a small card to stamp each order I have (similar to Stewart's milk card). Next time I get pizza in the area I'll definitely be back here. The family was friendly there was 2 guys and a young woman, there is also a small bakery to the right, will definitely have to try that next time. Pizza was also ready promptly in 12 ish minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are the most popular dishes at All in the Family Pizzeria?

    Customers rave about the pizza, especially the Meatball Parm pizza and Buffalo Chicken Sub. The hot wings are also a favorite!

  • Do I need a reservation to dine at the restaurant?

    Reservations are not required, so feel free to walk in whenever you're hungry!

  • What dining options are available?

    You can choose to dine in, takeout, or enjoy no-contact delivery at All in the Family Pizzeria.

  • What is the atmosphere like at the restaurant?

    The atmosphere is casual and quiet, making it a great spot for groups or solo dining. It’s especially nice for a quick bite during lunch or dinner.

  • Is parking available at the restaurant?

    Yes, there is free parking available both in the lot and on the street, plus it’s wheelchair accessible!

Nearby Pizza restaurants

Pizza restaurant
Little Mac's Pizzeria

1621 Grant Blvd, Syracuse, NY 13208

Pizza restaurant
Royas Great Neck Kosher Pizza

770 Middle Neck Rd # 3, Great Neck, NY 11024

Pizza restaurant
Wagon Wheel Pizza

2654 E Main St, Wappingers Falls, NY 12590

Pizza restaurant
Nino's Pizzeria

115 Main St, Port Byron, NY 13140

Pizza restaurant
Dreamer's Pizza

1850 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10029

Pizza restaurant
FRA AMICI PIZZA & PASTA

615 Hopkins St, Buffalo, NY 14220

Pizza restaurant
Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook

5 Huntington Ave, Lynbrook, NY 11563

Pizza restaurant
Village Pizza III

7514 N Broadway, Red Hook, NY 12571

Pizza restaurant
Mac's Pizza Shack

3250 Canandaigua Rd, Macedon, NY 14502

Pizza restaurant
Paesanos Pizzeria

10 S Main St #1813, Liberty, NY 12754

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page